Primitive Camping & Bushcraft

Mosquito Control: What Actually Works?

Episode Summary

Mosquitoes can turn a great camping trip into a miserable experience, and every outdoorsman seems to have a different opinion on how to deal with them. In this episode, Chris Speir explores common mosquito control methods, discusses years of experience using Thermacell products, and explains why the best solution is often the one you'll actually use.

Episode Notes

Mosquitoes have ruined more camping trips than bad weather, broken gear, and cold coffee combined.

In this episode, Chris Speir discusses one of the most common problems faced by campers, hunters, fishermen, and bushcrafters: mosquito control. Drawing from years of experience in South Mississippi, Alaska, deer camps, and conversations from the Primitive Camping & Bushcraft Facebook group, Chris breaks down several methods people use to keep mosquitoes at bay.

Topics include:

• Why mosquitoes can ruin an otherwise perfect trip

• Traditional methods including campfire smoke

• Dog fennel and American beautyberry

• DEET, Picaridin, and Permethrin

• Head nets and protective clothing

• Common mosquito myths and misconceptions

• How Thermacell products work

• Hunting with a Thermacell during bow season

• The new Thermacell Backpacker model

• Wind, setup time, and real-world limitations

• Why good gear solves problems

• Lessons learned from years outdoors

The biggest takeaway?

The gear is not the story.

The problem it solves is the story.

Join the discussion in the Primitive Camping & Bushcraft Facebook Group and let us know what mosquito control methods work best for you.

Remember:

"In all your ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct your paths." Proverbs 3:6

Episode Transcription

welcome back to

 

the Primitive

 

Camping and

 

Bushcraft podcast

 

my name is Chris

 

Speir and today

 

we're talking

 

about something

 

that can ruin an

 

otherwise

 

perfect camping

 

trip. Skeeter bugs,

 

mosquitoes, the

 

little winged

 

vampires. Yeah

 

those little

 

nuisances. You

 

know in my book

 

Primitive Camping

 

and Bushcraft on

 

page 80 I wrote

 

about mosquitoes

 

and biting

 

insects whenever

 

you were

 

selecting a site

 

for your shelter

 

and you know

 

there's

 

different ways to

 

control skeeter

 

bugs and that is

 

with natural

 

remedies like a

 

dog fennel or

 

American Beauty

 

Berry. A quick

 

history on

 

American Beauty

 

Berry it's

 

been used to

 

control insects

 

for ages. All the

 

pioneers whenever

 

they would

 

bed their

 

horses down or

 

whatever would

 

always put

 

American Beauty

 

Berry with them

 

and that

 

would control the

 

ticks and the

 

biting flies and

 

all that good

 

stuff all the

 

fleas and so

 

American Beauty

 

Berry is amazing

 

at mosquito

 

control

 

and I used a

 

bunch of the

 

leaves to make a

 

like a spray you

 

soak it in

 

alcohol and that

 

spray turns into

 

an amazing

 

mosquito

 

deterrent and

 

it's crazy it's

 

kind of like

 

an off in the

 

woods a natural

 

off so but now if

 

you spent any

 

amount of time in

 

the great

 

outdoors

 

especially down

 

here in South in

 

the South

 

Mississippi

 

or you

 

know the southern

 

United States you

 

already know

 

exactly what

 

I'm talking

 

about when it

 

comes to

 

mosquitoes heck

 

if you live in

 

Canada what kind

 

of flies

 

are that? and

 

mosquitoes are

 

horrible there in

 

Alaska the

 

mosquitoes are

 

ridiculous ask me

 

how I know but

 

you can have the

 

perfect campsite

 

the weather

 

can be beautiful

 

you can have a

 

fire burning you

 

know the coffee

 

is gonna be

 

good and hot the

 

fish are biting

 

everything can be

 

going exactly

 

according

 

to plan and those

 

mosquitoes start

 

showing up and

 

godly your

 

swatting

 

your ears

 

slapping your

 

neck scratching

 

your arms and

 

you're actually

 

they will

 

get you to

 

the point where

 

you're actually

 

considering is it

 

even worth

 

being out

 

here now I've

 

been in a

 

situation before

 

with camping on a

 

sandbar on the

 

river made a

 

couple of friends

 

and we we just

 

went out to the

 

sandbar drove a

 

boat out there

 

sat there all

 

night long fish

 

camped out and I

 

woke up the next

 

morning I'm

 

telling you I had

 

so many bug bites

 

on me it was

 

ridiculous like

 

ridiculous and I

 

just saw I was

 

like this is a

 

miserable we

 

didn't bring any

 

mosquito off we

 

didn't bring any

 

kind of repel any

 

kind of deep any

 

anything you

 

know we were

 

young enough and

 

that it was it

 

was crazy but

 

when you sit in

 

there swatting

 

your ears and

 

slapping your

 

neck all day it's

 

just like making

 

it misery so over

 

the last couple

 

of weeks I've had

 

several

 

conversations in

 

the group on

 

Facebook about

 

mosquito control

 

and it keeps

 

popping up every

 

time we we post

 

something else

 

there is always a

 

comment about

 

mosquitoes or

 

mosquito control

 

or one unit you

 

know it's like

 

whenever we were

 

talking about

 

items that we

 

thought were

 

gimmicks until we

 

tried it and it

 

just popped up

 

and it's called

 

the thermacell

 

and I'm trying to

 

remember if

 

I've done an

 

episode on

 

thermocell before

 

I don't recall

 

but some people

 

swear by them and

 

I am one I do

 

some people think

 

they're gimmicks

 

some people never

 

try one and

 

some people are

 

convinced that

 

they're nothing

 

more than another

 

expensive

 

gadget but the

 

funny thing is

 

thermos cells

 

were actually

 

brought

 

up several

 

times in the

 

group in recent

 

discussions about

 

gear and people

 

really thought

 

thermos cells

 

were a gimmick

 

until they

 

finally tried it

 

and that

 

really caught

 

my attention

 

because you know

 

I've been using

 

the thermos cell

 

for many years I

 

use the smaller

 

hunter variation

 

is the OD green

 

or the dark green

 

version and

 

it runs off a

 

little butane or

 

is it butane or

 

propane I don't

 

recall

 

but it's one

 

little cartridge

 

I think is a

 

butane cartridge

 

and it uses these

 

little pads

 

they're little

 

blue pads and you

 

put that

 

cartridge in and

 

you turn

 

it on and

 

you'll hear it

 

hiss like it is

 

it's letting the

 

propane or butane

 

escape and

 

then you got a

 

little burner

 

where you press

 

the button and it

 

ignites it and it

 

starts glowing

 

kind of like a

 

glow plug and

 

then it starts

 

putting

 

off some heat

 

and that heat

 

warms up that pad

 

and that pad

 

starts vaporizing

 

and it puts off a

 

odorless and you

 

can't see it you

 

know it's an

 

odorless cloud

 

that you

 

can't see

 

and it puts a

 

15-foot bubble

 

around you so

 

I've used them in

 

tree stands I've

 

used them in the

 

woods when I'm

 

walking around

 

I've used them

 

sitting in camp

 

I've put one on

 

one side of the

 

camp on on the

 

other side of the

 

camp and you know

 

I've recently

 

picked up the

 

backpacking

 

version that

 

screws directly

 

into a fuel

 

canister

 

like you'd use

 

for a jet boil or

 

something to that

 

effect so today I

 

thought we'd talk

 

about mosquitoes

 

mosquito control

 

what works

 

what doesn't

 

and why the

 

thermacell has

 

become so popular

 

in the outdoors

 

world now before

 

we get into the

 

thermosails let's

 

talk about

 

mosquitoes or

 

basically

 

the war on

 

mosquitoes in

 

general because

 

if you've been

 

camping for any

 

length of time

 

you've probably

 

heard almost

 

every skeeter bug

 

remedy known to

 

mankind and

 

when I say that

 

I'm talking about

 

dryer sheets

 

citronella

 

candles soaps

 

perfumes

 

shampoos eating

 

garlic burning

 

garlic vitamin B

 

bracelets

 

different clips

 

patches essential

 

oils and I mean

 

I've heard so

 

many stories

 

about oh use this

 

use that use this

 

one of the most

 

recent things

 

I've saw was

 

somebody

 

taking garlic

 

powder rolling it

 

up in cotton

 

balls and letting

 

it burn and it

 

puts off an odor

 

that the skeeters

 

can't stand and

 

they don't come

 

around and that

 

was on a short

 

video on TikTok

 

or something like

 

that no

 

matter of fact if

 

you've sat around

 

a campfire long

 

enough you've

 

probably heard

 

somebody swear

 

that dryer sheets

 

took under your

 

hat keeps the

 

mosquitoes away

 

then somebody

 

else will say no

 

don't then

 

somebody says

 

their grandpa

 

used this for 30

 

years and

 

somebody else

 

said centronella

 

is always

 

answered then

 

somebody

 

centronella don't

 

work the truth is

 

most of us don't

 

care about

 

marketing claims

 

only thing we

 

care about is

 

does it really

 

actually 100%

 

without a doubt

 

work for me

 

mosquitoes have

 

been a problem my

 

entire life all

 

all of my

 

outdoor time has

 

always been

 

plagued by

 

mosquitoes you

 

know down

 

here in South

 

Mississippi

 

they're

 

everywhere I mean

 

and especially in

 

early bow season

 

October November

 

you'd be sitting

 

at a tree stand

 

and try not to

 

move but

 

skeeters are

 

they're like

 

buzzing your head

 

and sometimes

 

it's so

 

bad that it's

 

just so bad it's

 

horrible but the

 

worst mosquitoes

 

I ever seen was

 

whenever I

 

lived in Alaska I

 

mean dude I'm

 

telling you them

 

things were bad

 

and you go out

 

into the woods in

 

Alaska and they

 

ate me alive and

 

I can remember

 

salmon fishing

 

in summertime and

 

you know

 

everybody is

 

elbow to elbow on

 

this creek

 

and they're

 

you know knee

 

high waist high

 

in the water and

 

everybody fishes

 

in a row and

 

everybody fishes

 

in rhythm so if

 

the person next

 

to you is

 

casting you're

 

casting so it

 

looks like

 

everybody's

 

casting all at

 

the same time

 

it's pretty

 

cool you say fish

 

down fish on

 

coming up coming

 

down everybody

 

reels their stuff

 

in gets out of

 

the way for you

 

you know but

 

still nonetheless

 

mosquitoes

 

all day

 

all night just

 

tearing you up

 

and the beautiful

 

thing about

 

Anchorage

 

whenever

 

I was there is

 

that we get off

 

work at five

 

o'clock we'd head

 

out there to go

 

fishing five

 

o'clock in the

 

morning we were

 

leaving to go

 

back to

 

work we were

 

still fishing and

 

I've seen it the

 

mosquitoes were

 

so bad in

 

Alaska they

 

called them the

 

state bird they

 

was crazy so I

 

remember whenever

 

I first got

 

there someone was

 

I don't know if

 

they were trying

 

to scare us

 

because I'd

 

never been there

 

before or

 

anything like

 

that but whenever

 

I first

 

got there one

 

of my in-process

 

and appointments

 

they were telling

 

me that

 

don't you get

 

caught without

 

any mosquito

 

protection

 

because they can

 

suck you

 

free of blood

 

eight hours now

 

hopefully that

 

was just an

 

exaggeration or

 

at least

 

I hope so

 

you know but the

 

mosquitoes up

 

there were no

 

joke so when

 

somebody starts

 

talking about

 

mosquito control

 

and listen to

 

them you might

 

learn something

 

but let's talk

 

about the

 

thermocell itself

 

one of the

 

biggest

 

misconceptions

 

is that people

 

think it's some

 

kind of mosquito

 

killing machine

 

it is not that

 

is definitely not

 

what it is it

 

doesn't attract

 

the mosquitoes it

 

don't zap on

 

or anything like

 

that you don't

 

suck them into

 

some kind of trap

 

it's just a

 

little device

 

that puts off a

 

15-foot diameter

 

bubble of

 

mosquito

 

repellent so

 

it creates this

 

little protection

 

zone all around

 

you and inside

 

that unit is

 

this little small

 

pad it's a little

 

blue pad and like

 

I explained

 

earlier the

 

unit heats that

 

pad excuse me and

 

that pad contains a

 

repellent called

 

allethrin

 

allethrin

 

allethrin

 

allethrin

 

allethrin

 

allethrin allethrin

 

allethrin

 

allethrin

 

and as the pad

 

warms up it's

 

it's got the

 

repellent it's

 

released

 

into the air all

 

around you and it

 

creates like I

 

said of an

 

invisible bubble

 

and the

 

mosquitoes

 

simply don't want

 

to be there now

 

this works

 

different than

 

sprays you know

 

sprays you put on

 

your skin or your

 

clothes and they

 

see you

 

don't have to

 

do that and you

 

know a thermosail

 

protects the

 

space around you

 

it's a big

 

difference and

 

one of the things

 

that people don't

 

realize is that

 

thermosails do

 

not work

 

instantly I've

 

seen where a

 

bunch of people

 

like hey this is

 

a gimmick this

 

thing don't work

 

but no it don't

 

it takes a

 

little while for

 

it to build up

 

it's got to build

 

up the heat it's

 

got to be

 

able to vaporize

 

that that

 

chemical and then

 

spit it out the

 

beautiful thing

 

about this is

 

that you don't

 

want to wait

 

until you start

 

getting to eat

 

alive to turn

 

your thermosail

 

on so you want to

 

go ahead and turn

 

it on whenever

 

I'm going hunting

 

I will actually

 

turn my

 

thermosail unit

 

on before I start

 

walking to my

 

stand that way

 

when I get to my

 

stand this all

 

heated up and it

 

starts putting

 

out that protects

 

that bubble of

 

protection so you

 

know with a

 

thermosail it

 

takes time to

 

build that zone

 

up and it's kind

 

of it's kind of

 

weird because I

 

was like I was

 

thinking about

 

this earlier and

 

it kind of

 

reminded me of

 

Noah I know he

 

probably like

 

worrying

 

the world's

 

ego it is no but

 

think about it

 

for a minute Noah

 

didn't start

 

building that

 

art when it was

 

started raining

 

he built it

 

before the storm

 

ever arrived he

 

built it before

 

there was a

 

problem and

 

that's something

 

that we see

 

throughout

 

the outdoors

 

people who stay

 

comfortable

 

aren't always are

 

aren't usually

 

the ones

 

reacting to the

 

problems they're

 

the ones

 

preparing

 

beforehand you

 

don't wait until

 

it's freezing

 

together you

 

firewood you

 

don't wait until

 

you're

 

lost and learn

 

how to use your

 

compass you don't

 

wait till you

 

dehydrated start

 

looking for

 

water you don't

 

wait until the

 

mosquitoes are

 

carrying you

 

away before

 

thinking about

 

mosquito control

 

good preparation

 

solves a lot of

 

problems

 

before they ever

 

become

 

emergencies and

 

that's really

 

what the

 

strength of the

 

thermosail really

 

is you turn it on

 

you let it do its

 

job by

 

the time the

 

mosquito bugs get

 

there you've

 

already prepared

 

for the problem

 

now another

 

thing many people

 

don't always

 

understand is

 

that the wind

 

really does

 

matter now this

 

thermosail it it

 

works by putting

 

a bubble around

 

you so if you

 

have the wind

 

it's gonna blow

 

your whole

 

protective zone

 

away that's one

 

of the downfalls

 

of using a

 

thermosail and if

 

the winds blowing

 

hard enough

 

it's going to

 

it's going to

 

disperse the zone

 

and that's just

 

you know

 

basically

 

common sense so a

 

very calm evening

 

or where the

 

thermosails

 

really shine so

 

if you're going

 

to go out and

 

you're going to

 

it's gonna be

 

windy or whatnot

 

you probably want

 

to have some

 

spray or

 

something to that

 

effect but

 

if you're

 

sitting around

 

camp you're

 

fishing on the

 

bank or you know

 

hunting in

 

a tree stand

 

then the

 

thermosail is

 

really going to

 

shine if it's not

 

really

 

windy but then

 

again if it's

 

real windy you're

 

not gonna have

 

many

 

mosquitoes so I've

 

learned that when

 

you relax and

 

around the fire

 

you're gonna get

 

the occasion

 

mosquitoes

 

they're gonna

 

come around the

 

backside of you

 

you know they're

 

gonna be away

 

from that smoke

 

there are a

 

couple of

 

different things

 

and I talked

 

about this

 

extensively in my

 

book using dog

 

fennel which is

 

natural using

 

American Beauty

 

Berry we talked

 

about it earlier

 

but anyway dog

 

fennel you can

 

take dog fennel

 

and I've done a

 

video of this you

 

get some coals

 

and you just

 

take some dog

 

fennel and you

 

lay green dog

 

fennel on top of

 

the coals

 

and just

 

a little smolder

 

and that that

 

smoke makes a

 

vapor barrier

 

just like the

 

thermosail does

 

and but it's all

 

natural and one

 

of the beautiful

 

things about

 

that is that

 

thermosail not

 

thermosail but

 

the dog fennel

 

can be

 

used to wipe

 

on your skin you

 

can rub it on

 

your skin and the

 

oils will

 

transfer

 

from the dog

 

fennel to your

 

skin and it will

 

help control the

 

mosquitoes it's

 

not gonna

 

riddle 100% but

 

it'll control the

 

mosquitoes and

 

plus if

 

you're looking

 

for a cover scent

 

for your deer

 

hunting it really

 

helps with that

 

as well so

 

thermosails

 

aren't the only

 

answer but they

 

have got to be

 

one of the

 

most most

 

effective devices

 

that I have found

 

to use for

 

mosquito control

 

and down here

 

in the south of

 

Mississippi I'm

 

telling you now

 

we got some

 

skeeters and these

 

things are

 

horrible and if

 

you're out

 

fishing during

 

the daytime

 

you're gonna

 

get mosquitoes

 

and you always

 

wear long sleeves

 

when I go out and

 

about into the

 

woods I do have

 

long sleeves on

 

now the problem

 

with that is most

 

of the time

 

they're real thin

 

long sleeves and

 

the skaters just

 

eat you through

 

the long

 

sleeves there's

 

other things out

 

there that you

 

can use smoke has

 

been used for

 

thousand years to

 

control

 

mosquitoes and

 

deep it works but

 

it also

 

causes cancer

 

deep's been

 

around forever

 

some people don't

 

want to put that

 

on their skin

 

some people don't

 

know about them.

 

Deet if you

 

squirt skater

 

spray on

 

stuff like

 

certain plastics

 

and stuff it will

 

eat the plastic

 

it will

 

deteriorate some

 

plastics. The

 

caridine I

 

believe the name

 

of it

 

P-I-C-A-R-I-D-I-N

 

it works

 

as good as

 

deep. One of the

 

ones that I've

 

always used

 

especially when I

 

was in the

 

military was

 

permethrin and

 

that stuff you

 

can get at the

 

local local feed

 

store they sell a

 

bottle of that

 

stuff and I think

 

it's like a 32

 

ounce bottle

 

it's only like 14

 

or 15 bucks

 

something like

 

that don't quote

 

me on the price

 

it's been a

 

couple years

 

since I bought it

 

because it lasts

 

forever

 

and you can

 

use it and treat

 

your clothes and

 

you just make

 

sure you wear

 

gloves you know

 

it is it is a

 

neurotoxin but

 

that's the

 

downside to it

 

make sure you

 

don't have

 

cats anywhere

 

around cats

 

because

 

permethrin will

 

kill your

 

cat but you

 

could put it on

 

your clothes and

 

you can dry your

 

clothes out and

 

then it's good

 

for like six to

 

ten washes or

 

whatever and it

 

will kill skaters

 

ticks you know

 

especially this

 

time of year you

 

want to have that

 

for ticks it

 

really really

 

does help with

 

ticks and it

 

works way better

 

than deet does or

 

anything like

 

that but

 

permethrin

 

permethrin you

 

can squirt it

 

around your house

 

you know

 

it'll keep fleas

 

down if you got

 

fleas if you got

 

dogs it that

 

stuff is amazing

 

stuff but like I

 

said it will kill

 

cats all of the

 

cats got it

 

is a lictar

 

paws that's

 

toasted and

 

they'll start

 

having seizures

 

and I've

 

had a company

 

for a month

 

straight like

 

almost every

 

other day for a

 

month and I'm

 

like look

 

I'm not

 

interested but

 

they have nets

 

that go around

 

your hat go

 

around your

 

head head nets or

 

whatever and

 

those work I mean

 

you see

 

pictures all the

 

ways back in the

 

50s 40s and 50s

 

with people

 

fishing and they

 

were using those

 

nets they were

 

matter of fact

 

they work

 

extremely well

 

the

 

downside is is that

 

most people don't

 

want to look like

 

they're

 

inspecting a

 

beehive so every

 

single mosquito

 

solution has a

 

trade-off and

 

that's really

 

what the

 

lesson of the

 

mosquito is you

 

know the goal is

 

it finding the

 

perfect solution

 

the goal is

 

finding the

 

solution that

 

actually you

 

could use and for

 

me it's been the

 

Thermacell and

 

I've used that

 

for a very very

 

long time for

 

somebody else it

 

might be deet

 

somebody else it

 

might be a head

 

net or a hat net

 

or whatever you

 

want to call it

 

and for some

 

people it might

 

be a combination

 

of several

 

different things

 

and that's

 

perfectly fine it

 

doesn't matter

 

like I've said a

 

hundred times is

 

all about the end

 

result it's not

 

about

 

them it's not

 

about looking

 

fancy it's about

 

the end result so

 

at the end of the

 

day good

 

gear solves

 

problems it don't

 

matter what it is

 

a bottle of DEET

 

is a thing

 

of gear and they

 

even got the DEET

 

the DEET they

 

even got the

 

DEET that is

 

works out like a

 

like a sunscreen

 

you know like a

 

lotion you just

 

squirt a

 

little on your

 

hands and you

 

wipe it on I've

 

used that

 

countless times

 

and that

 

tends to work a

 

lot better than

 

the spray does

 

for me because

 

you can put it

 

all around your

 

neck and

 

everything just

 

wipe a little bit

 

on your

 

hands and you

 

goes a very very

 

very long way and

 

I can't tell you

 

how many

 

times I have

 

repeatedly said

 

repeatedly

 

repeated on this

 

podcast is that

 

good gear solves

 

problems bad gear

 

creates problems

 

you know

 

essentially over

 

and over without

 

saying those

 

exact words is

 

it's all about

 

the end

 

result now the

 

thermosil solves

 

the problem just

 

like in water

 

purification

 

the grill

 

GeoPress is going

 

to solve a

 

problem so is the

 

Sawyer squeeze a

 

hammock is going

 

to solve a

 

problem a camp

 

chair is going to

 

solve a problem

 

you'll

 

start to see

 

what I'm talking

 

about y'all

 

starting to see

 

the pattern here

 

the gear

 

is not the

 

story the problem

 

that it solves is

 

the story the

 

problem that the

 

gear solves

 

is the main event

 

mosquitoes are a

 

problem and just

 

about every

 

campground hunter

 

fisher

 

outdoorsman

 

backpacker every

 

one of these

 

people if you do

 

anything in

 

outdoors and

 

mosquitoes are a

 

problem that you

 

have dealt with

 

at one point or

 

another

 

so

 

I want to throw

 

that question

 

back to you what

 

is your as my

 

beard keeps

 

touching this

 

thing oh

 

microphone what

 

is your favorite

 

mosquito

 

solution if

 

the mosquito is

 

the problem what

 

is your solution

 

is it a

 

thermosil is it a

 

deep the wipe on

 

kind or the

 

lotion guide is

 

it smoke you put

 

some dog

 

fennel down in

 

some coals and

 

let it vaporize

 

and create a good

 

bubble or

 

some American

 

beauty berry that

 

does the same

 

thing do you use

 

some kind of bug

 

net or something

 

to keep the

 

skeeter bugs off

 

of you I

 

heard do you use

 

something just

 

completely

 

different not the

 

wall I'd love to

 

hear it

 

I'd love to

 

find out what it

 

is so head on

 

over to the

 

primitive camping

 

and bushcraft

 

Facebook group

 

join in on the

 

conversation I

 

would love

 

to I would

 

genuinely

 

genuinely love to

 

know what works

 

for you because

 

if it works for

 

you it could

 

possibly work for

 

me is it easier

 

than thermosil

 

hmm I don't know

 

I found one yet

 

so remember guys

 

in all your ways

 

acknowledge him

 

and he shall

 

direct your paths

 

God bless you and

 

I'll see you

 

around the

 

campfire